Euan Ritchie's playground

Navigation

Search this site

Login More quotes… 
Expand all rantsList rants ordered backwards in timeList rants alphabetically

Of human nature

Aren't some of the connections between some scientific studies a bit obvious?

I was just reading an article about some scientists theory that instruction given with religious authority can make people more aggresive.

These people used some admitted religious and not so religious people in an experiment where they were tested (using some games) to find how agressive each person was. Then they were read passages of what they were told were biblical, or for some simply historic, text. And some people were read passages that explicitly ended with divine commandments of violence (such as "go forth and smite the whatits commanded the lord").

Then the participants were tested again. and the result was that people who were read texts commanding divine violence, no matter how religious or aggressive the person, or the presumed source of the text, became more agressive.

This doesn't surprise me, but not because I think it says anything about peoples religion. I think I already know what religion is and this fits with my theories about people.

Let's talk about Milgram, he of the famous experiments into authority. Milgram's the guy who got people in lab coats to tell participants in experiments to keep turning up the current on shocks being given to people to see how far they would go. And plenty of people keep going up to apparently lethal levels as long as an authority figure told them to.

Milgram was trying to find out how previously assummed peaceful and civilized citizens of Germany could not only abide but actively participate in the crimes of the fascists. He wanted to understand how someone could undoubtably see evil we're sure they'd been taught to reject but still cooperate with it.

Turns out people can be unreasonably cooperative with authority. And I think it's obvious why.

Humans are gregarious creatures. We are hard wired to desire company and acceptance. Subordination to leadership looks and feels to our hind brains like valued membership in a tribe.

Priests try to define the tribe granting themselves a valueable ledge on its totem pole and they use millenia of well practiced threats and rewards to encourage people to settle into a given, lower, place on that pole.

They recognize that the suggestion of command by authority speaks directly to our ape brain and that people simply find it easy and rewarding to obey.

It's annoying but's it's just how we are. People aren't that complicated.